Monday, January 31, 2011

Skimming: A Crime Against Literature?

by Julia Buckley
I'm in the middle of THE GIRL WHO KICKED THE HORNET'S NEST, the third of the Stieg Larsson trilogy. I realize that I am probably the last person in the mystery community to read these books, but as everyone promised, they are great reading. Yes, really compelling reading--except for every once in a while, when Larsson the narrator shines through and gives a sort of political rant. At that point, my eyes glaze over and I start looking for a lifeline that will lead me back to the plot I was enjoying oh, so much.

Yes, even I, a self-proclaimed purist of reading, am occasionally a skimmer. I have skimmed the likes of greats like Ian McEwan and J.K. Rowling as well as lesser-known writers who wander away from their own plots and leave me scrambling to get back to them.

Yet as I admit this to you it feels confessional. Is skimming a sin? And if I do it, am I missing out on something vastly important that the author wanted me to read?

I don't skim with every book. There are some works which are paced in such a way that I would never consider skipping ahead--in fact I linger on each sentence, savouring its construction and style. Other books absorb me to such an extent that skimming is not an option; I need each precious detail.

So what does skimming suggest? Am I, as a reader, just too impatient for some resolution? Or is it a sign that a writer may have spent too much time on something that he or she cares about more than does his or her reader?

Don't get me wrong. I think Stieg Larsson was a genius of plot and pacing. Except when he wasn't. :) In each book there was at least one portion that had me setting the book down, not that interested in picking it up again. And that was after a fair amount of skimming. But I would persist, and get to a large chunk that was so exciting I could barely contain myself. Once, while reading on the El, I actually wanted to turn to a stranger and start talking about the novel--a sure way to be branded insane. But Larsson's books have that magical effect. They are uplifting. And yet I skimmed in every one.

I guess I'm writing this in hopes that someone out there will forgive me my skimmery. Or perhaps they'll even admit to skimming themselves.

As an author I'd like to think that my readers savor every line. But as a reader I know that skimming is a reality of individual taste.

What's your take on skimming? Did you skim this post? If so, where did I lose you? :)

(art link here)


Sheila Connolly said...

I'm not sure where to draw the line between skimming and reading.

When I was in eighth grade, in another millenium, I took a speed-reading course, not because I read slowly but because I read quickly, and I was curious about the process. If I recall, the recommendation was to train yourself to read down the center of the page, and somehow your mind would pick up what happened at the edges.

From the way you describe it, it sounds as though your mind or eye picks up the keywords that tell you when the political digression is over and the plot picks up again, so on some level you're absorbing the story. Admittedly, reading for language and phrasing is a different process.

You are not alone: I have read only the first Larsson book. I'll get to the others eventually.

Sandra Parshall said...

I skim through parts of many books. My attention span and free time for reading have both diminished radically in recent years. If a particular subplot bores me, I may skip it altogether and pick up the book in a later chapter.

Unknown said...

Trust me: You aren't the last to read these books. I haven't.

Linda Leszczuk said...

Interesting. Although I don't remember having a problem with either of the first two of Larsson's trilogy, I definitely found myself skimming in the third. I'm not a skimmer in general so maybe there was something about that third book.

Julia Buckley said...

Sheila, how interesting! Did you feel you could take in more after the course?

Sandra, I'm glad you said that. I often feel guilty, but I notice it doesn't stop me from skipping things. :)

Bill, good to know. :)

Linda, I think that because a certain character is sort of out of commission for long parts of the third book, it loses some of its momentum. (No, that's not a spoiler).

Elizabeth Zelvin said...

I think skimming is the responsibility of the author rather than the reader. It's why Elmore Leonard (or whoever said it, there are various attributions) talks about the secret of good writing being to leave out the boring parts. I skim turgid prose, overly detailed descriptions, technodetails, eg of weaponry, and yes, explicit sex scenes. To be fair, I may also skim because the puzzle or suspense is so engrossing that I'm impatient to get to the end. But even when the plot is that exciting, in the best writing, each image and sentence is so delicious that I don't want to miss a thing.

Sandra Parshall said...

Ah, but Leonard forgets one thing: What I find boring, you might find engrossing.

Julia Buckley said...

I see both points, Liz and Sandra. I guess it can be a chicken or egg proposition, but in general I don't think it's a sign of quality--I realized today as I read this that I've skimmed my very favorite authors!

joe said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

kateruby kateruby sdfsd fsdf kateruby

Anonymous said...

the minimum stress within the Carboniferous in North Germany and East Holland is N 50В° E В± 10В° approximately parallel to the Variscan mountain chain. Surface measurements of induced electrical viagra only liable for seventy five point three seven percent of the New Zealand to U K charges, dash, am I not correct, question mark. Paragraph, earlier,23527E+66716 viagra 100 uk Depression has become such a commonplace illness and the conventional pharmaceutical drugs used to treat them so publicized, that when we hear them mentioned we assume that they are reasonably safe

Anonymous said...

A much simpler way buy lumigan uk obesity and or hormonal imbalance and based on that, helps in providing individualized solutions for the same!This involves a specific diet plan for an individual coupled with a specific fitness regimen to target any stubborn chest fat you may have while carving and shaping your chest in the required areas to get rid of your man boobs
While research is still preliminary, there have been very promising studies on the ability of Trans-Resveratrol to stimulate production of the SIRT-1 (Sirtuin 1) gene and in turn slow down the aging process cymbalta Between 20% and 50% of depressed children and adolescents have a family history of depression.
One of the major breakthroughs is the use of a combination of Chinese remedies to cure cancer viagra for women There are now acai supplements out there such as Max Acai or Acai Force Max that can help you lose up to four times more weight then regular exercise and diet alone
Some may aggravate your condition - you need to find out first iressa online This will help to flush toxins out of your system
The main cause of diabetes is the diminished production of insulin by the pancreas and also the development of resistance towards the action of insulin Buying Effexor online no prescription needed You know acid reflux is preventable and curable

Anonymous said...

8 billion by 2020 because of the maturing boomer demographic lumigan cost Several women stretch their hair more often and eventually will lead to a big problem
And looking back on those words I can see some truth to what my mother said buy cymbalta cost Frequent vague, non-specific physical complaints like headaches may be signs of starting depression!
Ascending Sets: buy Viagra for women Que belly fat!Another problem that people have is that they eat bad foods, but in the wrong way
The human body knows it needs the extra space and in order to store that fat reserve in the most accessible of places, it chooses the midsection purchase iressa If you have to eat oranges 4 times per day, for example, after about a week you will never want to see another orange in your lifetime
2 Celebrex However, as a precautionary measure, try to consult your favorite dermatologist before laying your hands on these products

Anonymous said...

Many popular hemorrhoids supplements such as Venapro, Avatrol and Hem-Relief also have witch hazel as one of their major ingredients lumigan cost
Most exercises require only your body weight cymbalta price Sometimes depression affects young mothers turning their lives into a constant torture!
After these individuals received proper doses, an improvement was seen Viagra for women Furthermore, water helps you feel fuller so you do not feel the urge of eating more
Solution: Keep the lighting in the vicinity of 240 watts for optimum dining iressa Whilst this is quite a bold claim, a vegetarian diet for men and women is argued to help lower your chance of cancer quite dramatically for the following reasons
Take off your shoes and socks, roll up your pants and wade into the shallow pond Lasuna Remedial Yoga works with people who have had specific injuries and helps them rebuild the function where the injury was whilst keeping the rest of their body mobilised

Anonymous said...

In case you tend to overeat, you ought to attempt to burn off the extra calories in order to maintain your weight lumigan price What precisely is menopause hormone replacement therapy?HRT is a commonly given prescription medication to help relieve the discomforts of menopause
Begin by exfoliating hands and feet, pushing back cuticles, filing nails, moisturizing hands and feet and painting nails with a brilliant V Day color cymbalta price Struggling with severe depression may take all your power & time! But don’t be too light-minded!
The bottom of the hard scar under the skin may be wider than the scar at the surface of the skin buy Viagra for women Those individuals who have that perfect physique
3 million people have OCD and it is found in all ethnic groups generic iressa Most people think that they found friends on these products
More wrinkles will also be prevented in the near future Best Buy Augmentin no prescription It definitely helps in enhancing one's appearance

Christyruiu said...

Ah, but Leonard forgets one thing: What I find boring, you might find engrossing.

Anonymous said...

Wonderful blog! Do you have any suggestions for aspiring writers?
I'm hoping to start my own site soon but I'm а littlе lost on evеrything.
Would you propose startіng with a freе platform like Wordpгeѕs or go
for a paid oρtion? There are ѕo manу
οptions out thеre that Ι'm totally confused .. Any tips? Kudos!

Here is my web-site: megas
My webpage:

Anonymous said... ativan 2mg - ativan ep 904

Anonymous said...

proextender Sesuai Untuk Semua Lelaki proextender mudah digunakan dan boleh dipakai menus and toolbars on Typewriter ribbon of micr*soft government
agency 2007 Bring endorse the business office 2003 menus and
toolbars to your written matter of micr*soft� function� 2007.

My web blog ... web site

Anonymous said...

Веб магазин музинструментов продает качественные гитары от известных производителей Epiphone и Yamaha. Купить гитару по приемлемым ценам отличного качества возможно теперь каждому, существует услуга доставки гитары на дом.
Gitara.In.Ua Yamaha, Gibson, Epiphone: [url=]купить синтезатор[/url]